Data

Data and code from: Plant species responses to nutrient addition, but not to herbivore exclusion, strengthen over time in global grasslands

Charles Sturt University
Nutrient Network (NutNet) ; Borer, Elizabeth ; Seabloom, Eric ; Slette, Ingrid ; Porath-Krause, Anita ; Wilfahrt, Peter ; Asmus, Ashley ; Lind, Eric ; O'Halloran, Lydia ; Adler, Peter ; Akasaka, Munemitsu ; Alberti, Juan ; Anderson, T. ; Baez, Selene ; Bahamonde, Hector ; Bakker, Jonathan ; Bakker, Liesbeth ; Barrio, Isabel ; Biederman, Lori ; Blumenthal, Dana ; Böhner, Hanna ; Boughton, Elizabeth ; Bråthen, Kari Anne ; Brown, Cynthia ; Brudvig, Lars ; Buckley, Yvonne ; Bugalho, Miguel ; Cadotte, Marc ; Caldeira, Maria ; Carbutt, Clinton ; Catford, Jane ; Chaneton, Enrique ; Chu, Chengjin ; Cleland, Elsa ; Collins, Scott ; Cottingham, Kathryn ; Crawley, Mick ; Daleo, Pedro ; Damschen, Ellen ; D’Antonio, Carla ; Davies, Kendi ; DeCrappeo, Nicole ; Dickson, Tim ; Donohue, Ian ; Du, Guozhen ; DuPre, Mary Ellyn ; Dwyer, John ; Ebeling, Anne ; Eisenhauer, Nico ; Eskelinen, Anu ; Estrada, Catalina ; Fay, Philip ; Firn, Jennifer ; Gruner, Daniel ; Güsewell, Sabine ; Hagenah, Nicole ; Haider, Sylvia ; Hallett, Lauren ; Harpole, W. ; Hautier, Yann ; Hector, Andy ; Hersch-Green, Erika ; Hille Ris Lambers, Janneke ; Hofmockel, Kirsten ; Jamiyansharav, Khishigbayar ; Jentsch, Anke ; Jónsdóttir, Ingibjörg ; Kadoya, Taku ; Kay, Adam ; Kirkman, Kevin ; Klein, Julia ; Knapp, Alan ; Knight, Tiffany ; Knops, Johannes ; Koerner, Sally ; Komatsu, Kimberly ; Laanisto, Lauri ; Ladwig, Laura ; Lannes, Lucíola ; Leakey, Andrew ; Lekberg, Ylva ; Li, Qi ; Li, Wei ; Lkhagva, Ariuntsetseg ; MacDougall, Andrew ; Macek, Petr ; Martina, Jason ; Martinson, Holly ; McCulley, Rebecca ; Melbourne, Brett ; Mitchell, Charles ; Mitchell, Rachel ; Moore, Joslin ; Morgan, John ; Mortensen, Brent ; Nelson, Jim ; Ochoa-Hueso, Raul ; Ohlert, Tim ; olde Venterink, Harry ; Orr, Devyn ; Orrock, John ; Osborne, Brooke ; Paper, Janet ; Peri, Pablo ; Power, Sally ; Price, Jodi ; Prober, Suzanne ; Pyke, David ; Raynaud, Xavier ; Reed, Sasha ; Ren, Zhengwei ; Richards, Anna ; Risch, Anita ; Roscher, Christiane ; Sankaran, Mahesh ; Schuetz, Martin ; Silveira, Maria ; Smith, Melinda ; Smith, Nicholas ; Speziale, Karina ; Spohn, Marie ; Standish, Rachel ; Stevens, Carly ; Sullivan, Lauren ; Tedder, Michelle ; Tognetti, Pedro ; Veen, G. F. Ciska ; Virtanen, Risto ; Wallace, Alison ; Wardle, Glenda ; Wedin, David ; Weiss, Arthur ; Wen, Gang ; Wheeler, George ; Wolkovich, Elizabeth ; Wragg, Peter ; Wright, Justin ; Yahdjian, Laura ; Yang, Louie ; Young, Alyssa ; Young, Hillary ; Li, Wenhuai
Viewed: [[ro.stat.viewed]] Cited: [[ro.stat.cited]] Accessed: [[ro.stat.accessed]]
ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Adc&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2FANDS&rft_id=info:doi10.5061/dryad.6m905qgfx&rft.title=Data and code from: Plant species responses to nutrient addition, but not to herbivore exclusion, strengthen over time in global grasslands&rft.identifier=10.5061/dryad.6m905qgfx&rft.publisher=Dryad&rft.description=Nutrient enrichment and altered herbivory are among the most pervasive drivers of change in grasslands worldwide, yet how their effects on plant communities accumulate or fade over time, and which species drive those effects, remains poorly resolved. Using long-term data from the Nutrient Network (NutNet), a globally distributed experiment, we examined how grassland plant community composition responded to factorial nutrient addition (NPK) and herbivore exclusion (fencing) across 98 sites and up to 12 years of treatment. For each site and year, we quantified the overall compositional difference between treatments (PERMANOVA), identified the species contributing most to those differences (SIMPER), and classified species as indicators of each treatment (Indicator Species Analysis), linking these responses to each species' dominance, commonness, functional group, lifespan, and provenance. We found that compositional divergence under nutrient addition strengthened over time and was driven disproportionately by a relatively small subset of species, particularly dominant and common ones, whereas the effects of herbivore exclusion were comparatively weak and transient. These results highlight the importance of species-level dynamics for understanding how grassland biodiversity responds to global change. This package provides the processed data and annotated R code needed to reproduce all analyses and figures in the associated study.&rft.creator=Nutrient Network (NutNet) &rft.creator=Borer, Elizabeth &rft.creator=Seabloom, Eric &rft.creator=Slette, Ingrid &rft.creator=Porath-Krause, Anita &rft.creator=Wilfahrt, Peter &rft.creator=Asmus, Ashley &rft.creator=Lind, Eric &rft.creator=O'Halloran, Lydia &rft.creator=Adler, Peter &rft.creator=Akasaka, Munemitsu &rft.creator=Alberti, Juan &rft.creator=Anderson, T. &rft.creator=Baez, Selene &rft.creator=Bahamonde, Hector &rft.creator=Bakker, Jonathan &rft.creator=Bakker, Liesbeth &rft.creator=Barrio, Isabel &rft.creator=Biederman, Lori &rft.creator=Blumenthal, Dana &rft.creator=Böhner, Hanna &rft.creator=Boughton, Elizabeth &rft.creator=Bråthen, Kari Anne &rft.creator=Brown, Cynthia &rft.creator=Brudvig, Lars &rft.creator=Buckley, Yvonne &rft.creator=Bugalho, Miguel &rft.creator=Cadotte, Marc &rft.creator=Caldeira, Maria &rft.creator=Carbutt, Clinton &rft.creator=Catford, Jane &rft.creator=Chaneton, Enrique &rft.creator=Chu, Chengjin &rft.creator=Cleland, Elsa &rft.creator=Collins, Scott &rft.creator=Cottingham, Kathryn &rft.creator=Crawley, Mick &rft.creator=Daleo, Pedro &rft.creator=Damschen, Ellen &rft.creator=D’Antonio, Carla &rft.creator=Davies, Kendi &rft.creator=DeCrappeo, Nicole &rft.creator=Dickson, Tim &rft.creator=Donohue, Ian &rft.creator=Du, Guozhen &rft.creator=DuPre, Mary Ellyn &rft.creator=Dwyer, John &rft.creator=Ebeling, Anne &rft.creator=Eisenhauer, Nico &rft.creator=Eskelinen, Anu &rft.creator=Estrada, Catalina &rft.creator=Fay, Philip &rft.creator=Firn, Jennifer &rft.creator=Gruner, Daniel &rft.creator=Güsewell, Sabine &rft.creator=Hagenah, Nicole &rft.creator=Haider, Sylvia &rft.creator=Hallett, Lauren &rft.creator=Harpole, W. &rft.creator=Hautier, Yann &rft.creator=Hector, Andy &rft.creator=Hersch-Green, Erika &rft.creator=Hille Ris Lambers, Janneke &rft.creator=Hofmockel, Kirsten &rft.creator=Jamiyansharav, Khishigbayar &rft.creator=Jentsch, Anke &rft.creator=Jónsdóttir, Ingibjörg &rft.creator=Kadoya, Taku &rft.creator=Kay, Adam &rft.creator=Kirkman, Kevin &rft.creator=Klein, Julia &rft.creator=Knapp, Alan &rft.creator=Knight, Tiffany &rft.creator=Knops, Johannes &rft.creator=Koerner, Sally &rft.creator=Komatsu, Kimberly &rft.creator=Laanisto, Lauri &rft.creator=Ladwig, Laura &rft.creator=Lannes, Lucíola &rft.creator=Leakey, Andrew &rft.creator=Lekberg, Ylva &rft.creator=Li, Qi &rft.creator=Li, Wei &rft.creator=Lkhagva, Ariuntsetseg &rft.creator=MacDougall, Andrew &rft.creator=Macek, Petr &rft.creator=Martina, Jason &rft.creator=Martinson, Holly &rft.creator=McCulley, Rebecca &rft.creator=Melbourne, Brett &rft.creator=Mitchell, Charles &rft.creator=Mitchell, Rachel &rft.creator=Moore, Joslin &rft.creator=Morgan, John &rft.creator=Mortensen, Brent &rft.creator=Nelson, Jim &rft.creator=Ochoa-Hueso, Raul &rft.creator=Ohlert, Tim &rft.creator=olde Venterink, Harry &rft.creator=Orr, Devyn &rft.creator=Orrock, John &rft.creator=Osborne, Brooke &rft.creator=Paper, Janet &rft.creator=Peri, Pablo &rft.creator=Power, Sally &rft.creator=Price, Jodi &rft.creator=Prober, Suzanne &rft.creator=Pyke, David &rft.creator=Raynaud, Xavier &rft.creator=Reed, Sasha &rft.creator=Ren, Zhengwei &rft.creator=Richards, Anna &rft.creator=Risch, Anita &rft.creator=Roscher, Christiane &rft.creator=Sankaran, Mahesh &rft.creator=Schuetz, Martin &rft.creator=Silveira, Maria &rft.creator=Smith, Melinda &rft.creator=Smith, Nicholas &rft.creator=Speziale, Karina &rft.creator=Spohn, Marie &rft.creator=Standish, Rachel &rft.creator=Stevens, Carly &rft.creator=Sullivan, Lauren &rft.creator=Tedder, Michelle &rft.creator=Tognetti, Pedro &rft.creator=Veen, G. F. Ciska &rft.creator=Virtanen, Risto &rft.creator=Wallace, Alison &rft.creator=Wardle, Glenda &rft.creator=Wedin, David &rft.creator=Weiss, Arthur &rft.creator=Wen, Gang &rft.creator=Wheeler, George &rft.creator=Wolkovich, Elizabeth &rft.creator=Wragg, Peter &rft.creator=Wright, Justin &rft.creator=Yahdjian, Laura &rft.creator=Yang, Louie &rft.creator=Young, Alyssa &rft.creator=Young, Hillary &rft.creator=Li, Wenhuai &rft.date=2026&rft.type=dataset&rft.language=English Access the data

Access:

Open

Full description

Nutrient enrichment and altered herbivory are among the most pervasive drivers of change in grasslands worldwide, yet how their effects on plant communities accumulate or fade over time, and which species drive those effects, remains poorly resolved. Using long-term data from the Nutrient Network (NutNet), a globally distributed experiment, we examined how grassland plant community composition responded to factorial nutrient addition (NPK) and herbivore exclusion (fencing) across 98 sites and up to 12 years of treatment. For each site and year, we quantified the overall compositional difference between treatments (PERMANOVA), identified the species contributing most to those differences (SIMPER), and classified species as indicators of each treatment (Indicator Species Analysis), linking these responses to each species' dominance, commonness, functional group, lifespan, and provenance. We found that compositional divergence under nutrient addition strengthened over time and was driven disproportionately by a relatively small subset of species, particularly dominant and common ones, whereas the effects of herbivore exclusion were comparatively weak and transient. These results highlight the importance of species-level dynamics for understanding how grassland biodiversity responds to global change. This package provides the processed data and annotated R code needed to reproduce all analyses and figures in the associated study.

Notes

External Organisations
Nutrient Network (NutNet); University of Minnesota; Utah State University; Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology; National University of Mar del Plata; Wake Forest University; National Polytechnic School; Universidad Nacional de la Patagonia Austral (UNPA)-CONICET; UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON; Netherlands Institute of Ecology; Agricultural University of Iceland; Iowa State University; Agricultural Research Service; The University of Tromsø; Archbold Biological Station; UiT The Arctic University of Norway; Colorado State University; Michigan State University; Trinity College Dublin; University of Lisbon; University of Toronto Scarborough; University of KwaZulu-Natal; Australian National University; Universidad de Buenos Aires; Lanzhou University; University of California San Diego; University of New Mexico; Dartmouth College; Imperial College London; University of Wisconsin-Madison; University of California, Santa Barbara; University of Colorado at Boulder; United States Geological Survey; University of Nebraska at Omaha; MPG Ranch; The University of Queensland; Friedrich Schiller University Jena; Leipzig University; German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv); Queensland University of Technology; University of Maryland; ETH Zurich; University of Pretoria; Leuphana University Lüneburg; University of Oregon; Utrecht University; University of Zurich; Michigan Technological University; University of Bayreuth; University of Iceland; University of Tsukuba; University of Saint Thomas; Washington University in St. Louis; University of Nebraska; University of North Carolina Greensboro; Estonian University of Life Sciences; University of São Paulo; University of Illinois; Northwest Institute of Plateau Biology, Chinese Academy of Sciences; National University of Mongolia; University of Guelph; Centre for Cancer Biology; Texas State University; McDaniel College; University of Kentucky; University of North Carolina; Northern Arizona University; State Government of Victoria; La Trobe University; Benedictine College; Universidad de Cádiz; Vrije Universiteit Brussel; Oregon State University; National University of Austral Patagonia; Western Sydney University; CSIRO; Sorbonne Université, Observatoire de Paris; Estellus, Paris; Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation; Snow and Landscape Research; National Centre for Biological Sciences India; University of Florida; Texas Tech University; Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas; Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences; University of Western Australia; Lancaster University; Agricultural Plant Physiology and Ecology Research Institute; University of Oulu; Minnesota State University Moorhead; The University of Sydney; University of British Columbia; Duke University; Matilda Handsley-Davis; Inner Mongolia University
Associated Persons
Nutrient Network (NutNet) (Creator); Borer, Elizabeth (Creator); Seabloom, Eric (Creator); Slette, Ingrid (Creator); Porath-Krause, Anita (Creator); Wilfahrt, Peter (Creator); Asmus, Ashley (Creator); Lind, Eric (Creator); O'Halloran, Lydia (Creator); Adler, Peter (Creator); Akasaka, Munemitsu (Creator); Alberti, Juan (Creator); Anderson, T. (Creator); Baez, Selene (Creator); Bahamonde, Hector (Creator); Bakker, Jonathan (Creator); Bakker, Liesbeth (Creator); Barrio, Isabel (Creator); Biederman, Lori (Creator); Blumenthal, Dana (Creator); Böhner, Hanna (Creator); Boughton, Elizabeth (Creator); Bråthen, Kari Anne (Creator); Brown, Cynthia (Creator); Brudvig, Lars (Creator); Buckley, Yvonne (Creator); Bugalho, Miguel (Creator); Cadotte, Marc (Creator); Caldeira, Maria (Creator); Carbutt, Clinton (Creator); Catford, Jane (Creator); Chaneton, Enrique (Creator); Chu, Chengjin (Creator); Cleland, Elsa (Creator); Collins, Scott (Creator); Cottingham, Kathryn (Creator); Crawley, Mick (Creator); Daleo, Pedro (Creator); Damschen, Ellen (Creator); D’Antonio, Carla (Creator); Davies, Kendi (Creator); DeCrappeo, Nicole (Creator); Dickson, Tim (Creator); Donohue, Ian (Creator); Du, Guozhen (Creator); DuPre, Mary Ellyn (Creator); Dwyer, John (Creator); Ebeling, Anne (Creator); Eisenhauer, Nico (Creator); Eskelinen, Anu (Creator); Estrada, Catalina (Creator); Fay, Philip (Creator); Firn, Jennifer (Creator); Gruner, Daniel (Creator); Güsewell, Sabine (Creator); Hagenah, Nicole (Creator); Haider, Sylvia (Creator); Hallett, Lauren (Creator); Harpole, W. (Creator); Hautier, Yann (Creator); Hector, Andy (Creator); Hersch-Green, Erika (Creator); Hille Ris Lambers, Janneke (Creator); Hofmockel, Kirsten (Creator); Jamiyansharav, Khishigbayar (Creator); Jentsch, Anke (Creator); Jónsdóttir, Ingibjörg (Creator); Kadoya, Taku (Creator); Kay, Adam (Creator); Kirkman, Kevin (Creator); Klein, Julia (Creator); Knapp, Alan (Creator); Knight, Tiffany (Creator); Knops, Johannes (Creator); Koerner, Sally (Creator); Komatsu, Kimberly (Creator); Laanisto, Lauri (Creator); Ladwig, Laura (Creator); Lannes, Lucíola (Creator); Leakey, Andrew (Creator); Lekberg, Ylva (Creator); Li, Qi (Creator); Li, Wei (Creator); Lkhagva, Ariuntsetseg (Creator); MacDougall, Andrew (Creator); Macek, Petr (Creator); Martina, Jason (Creator); Martinson, Holly (Creator); McCulley, Rebecca (Creator); Melbourne, Brett (Creator); Mitchell, Charles (Creator); Mitchell, Rachel (Creator); Moore, Joslin (Creator); Morgan, John (Creator); Mortensen, Brent (Creator); Nelson, Jim (Creator); Ochoa-Hueso, Raul (Creator); Ohlert, Tim (Creator); olde Venterink, Harry (Creator); Orr, Devyn (Creator); Orrock, John (Creator); Osborne, Brooke (Creator); Paper, Janet (Creator); Peri, Pablo (Creator); Power, Sally (Creator); Prober, Suzanne (Creator); Pyke, David (Creator); Raynaud, Xavier (Creator); Reed, Sasha (Creator); Ren, Zhengwei (Creator); Richards, Anna (Creator); Risch, Anita (Creator); Roscher, Christiane (Creator); Sankaran, Mahesh (Creator); Schuetz, Martin (Creator); Silveira, Maria (Creator); Smith, Melinda (Creator); Smith, Nicholas (Creator); Speziale, Karina (Creator); Spohn, Marie (Creator); Standish, Rachel (Creator); Stevens, Carly (Creator); Sullivan, Lauren (Creator); Tedder, Michelle (Creator); Tognetti, Pedro (Creator); Veen, G. F. Ciska (Creator); Virtanen, Risto (Creator); Wallace, Alison (Creator); Wardle, Glenda (Creator); Wedin, David (Creator); Weiss, Arthur (Creator); Wen, Gang (Creator); Wheeler, George (Creator); Wolkovich, Elizabeth (Creator); Wragg, Peter (Creator); Wright, Justin (Creator); Yahdjian, Laura (Creator); Yang, Louie (Creator); Young, Alyssa (Creator); Young, Hillary (Creator); Li, Wenhuai (Creator)

Created: 2026-08-25 to 2026-08-25

Issued: 2026-08-25

This dataset is part of a larger collection

Click to explore relationships graph

User Contributed Tags    

Login to tag this record with meaningful keywords to make it easier to discover

Identifiers
ACN 633 798 857